Choosing a legendary player to return and play for Collingwood Football Club is a fascinating and subjective exercise. The club has an illustrious history, stretching back to its formation in 1892, with countless champions who have donned the famous black-and-white guernsey. If Collingwood were to bring back a player from history, the choice would likely depend on the specific needs of the modern game and the unique attributes of the player in question.
Here’s a deep dive into a few of Collingwood’s most iconic players, their significance, and why they might be chosen for a hypothetical return in today’s AFL.
—
Gordon Coventry: The King of Goal Kickers
If there’s one player who could completely transform Collingwood’s modern-day attack, it’s the legendary Gordon Coventry.
Why Gordon Coventry?
Coventry is the greatest goal-scorer in Collingwood’s history and one of the most prolific in AFL/VFL history. Playing between 1920 and 1937, he amassed a staggering 1,299 goals, a record that stood unchallenged for over 60 years until broken by Tony Lockett. Known for his strength, impeccable marking ability, and deadly accuracy, Coventry was the focal point of Collingwood’s forward line during its golden era, which included the famous “Machine Team” that won four consecutive premierships from 1927 to 1930.
How Would He Fit in Today’s AFL?
In today’s game, where high-scoring forwards who can dominate aerial contests are prized, Coventry would be invaluable. At 185 cm (considered tall for his era) and with remarkable athleticism, Coventry could still excel in a modern forward line. With midfielders like Nick Daicos feeding him precision inside-50 deliveries, Coventry’s goal-scoring ability could make Collingwood virtually unstoppable.
—
Nathan Buckley: The Midfield Maestro
Nathan Buckley is one of the most revered figures in Collingwood’s history. As both a player and a coach, his contributions to the club are immense.
Why Nathan Buckley?
Buckley was a generational talent, renowned for his leadership, professionalism, and elite skills. Playing from 1994 to 2007, he won the 2003 Brownlow Medal and six Copeland Trophies (Collingwood’s Best and Fairest award). His kicking skills, decision-making, and composure under pressure were unparalleled, and he was instrumental in leading the club during the late 1990s and early 2000s.
How Would He Fit in Today’s AFL?
In a midfield dominated by young stars like Nick and Josh Daicos, Buckley would add veteran leadership and an unmatched level of class. His ability to hit targets with precision from long distances would complement Collingwood’s high-paced, attacking style perfectly. Moreover, his experience and leadership would further strengthen a side aiming for sustained premiership success.
—
Lou Richards: The Inspirational Leader
Lou Richards, affectionately known as “Louie the Lip,” is one of the most beloved figures in Collingwood’s history. While not as statistically dominant as Coventry or Buckley, Richards brought an intangible quality to the club that went beyond his on-field exploits.
Why Lou Richards?
Playing from 1941 to 1955, Richards was a small forward and rover known for his tenacity, wit, and leadership. He captained Collingwood to the 1953 premiership, ending the club’s 17-year premiership drought. After his playing career, Richards became a legendary media personality, forever linking his name with Collingwood and the AFL.
How Would He Fit in Today’s AFL?
Richards would be an ideal fit for today’s game as a pressure forward. In a modern AFL team, where forward pressure and tackling are critical, his relentless pursuit of the ball and opponents would make him a perfect addition. His leadership and charisma would also galvanize the team both on and off the field.
—
Dick Lee: The High-Flying Forward
Dick Lee, nicknamed “The Wizard of the Wing,” was one of the earliest superstars of the VFL and a trailblazer for the Collingwood Football Club.
Why Dick Lee?
Lee played from 1906 to 1922, kicking 707 goals in 230 games. Known for his high-flying marks and athleticism, he was a fan favorite and one of the most exciting players of his era. Lee won Collingwood’s goal-kicking award 11 times and was instrumental in their 1917 premiership.
How Would He Fit in Today’s AFL?
In the modern game, Lee’s agility and aerial prowess would make him a nightmare matchup for opposition defenders. His ability to create scoring opportunities from nothing would add a new dimension to Collingwood’s forward line. Additionally, Lee’s flair and crowd-pleasing style would draw fans to the game in droves.
—
Bob Rose: The Courageous Champion
Bob Rose is often remembered as the embodiment of Collingwood’s spirit and values. His resilience, determination, and love for the club left a lasting legacy.
Why Bob Rose?
Rose played from 1946 to 1955 and was a brilliant midfielder known for his courage, toughness, and consistency. He won four Copeland Trophies and was widely regarded as one of the best players of his era. Despite suffering a career-ending injury, Rose remained deeply connected to Collingwood as a coach and mentor.
How Would He Fit in Today’s AFL?
Rose would be the perfect midfield enforcer in today’s AFL. His toughness and contested-ball ability would complement Collingwood’s running game, providing balance and grit to the side. His inspirational story and commitment to the club would also serve as a rallying point for players and fans alike.
—
Jock McHale: The Legendary Coach and Player
While Jock McHale is best known as the longest-serving coach in AFL/VFL history, his contributions as a player were equally significant.
Why Jock McHale?
McHale played 261 games for Collingwood from 1903 to 1920 and was renowned for his endurance, intelligence, and tactical awareness. As a coach, he led the club to eight premierships, including the historic four-peat from 1927 to 1930.
How Would He Fit in Today’s AFL?
While McHale’s coaching legacy is unparalleled, his playing career would also translate well into the modern game. His work ethic and leadership would be invaluable in today’s demanding AFL environment, and his deep understanding of the game would make him a crucial asset on the field.
—
Why Gordon Coventry Stands Out
If Collingwood could choose just one player to bring back, Gordon Coventry might be the ideal choice. The current AFL landscape values dominant key forwards who can turn games on their own, and Coventry’s incredible goal-scoring ability would make him a generational talent even today. His presence in the forward line would alleviate pressure on Collingwood’s midfield and smaller forwards, creating a more dynamic and unpredictable attack.
—
Final Thoughts
Collingwood’s history is filled with legendary figures who have shaped the club’s identity and success. Whether it’s Gordon Coventry’s goal-kicking heroics, Nathan Buckley’s midfield brilliance, or Lou Richards’ inspirational leadership, each player brings unique qualities that could transform the modern team.
Ultimately, the choice of which legend to bring back would depend on the team’s needs and the era in which they play. For Collingwood fans, imagining these icons returning to the field is a testament to the club’s rich history and the enduring legacy of its champions.